Liquidator Moira Carter. Federal Court judge Scott Goodman has rejected arguments seeking to block an amendment to an originating process that calls for the removal of the liquidator of Australian Vocational Learning Institute Pty Ltd (AVLI). As told in LFI Ventures Pty Ltd v Carter, in the matter of Australian Vocational Learning Institute Pty Ltd (in liq) [2021] FCA 1555, the arguments against inclusion of…
Telling an insolvency practitioner their application for additional remuneration is “misconceived” is like telling Bill Shorten his plan for getting the ALP into power would work if only the plan’s primary beneficiary wasn’t himself. Red rags ain’t in it. So when an eminence of the Federal Circuit Court in Tasmania told trustee Brett Harrison that his application for a modest sum of future additional remuneration…
KPMG’s Andrew Smith. KPMG’s Martin Jones. ASIC’s record of litigation against registered liquidators continues to resist improvement, with a judge yesterday labelling the regulator’s bid to induce him to slash the fees of two voluntary administrators (VAs) as “unprincipled” and “wholly pointless”. “It was never viable to differentiate work that was said to be ‘tainted’, from work said not to be. If it is ASIC’s…
Hall Chadwick partner Blair Pleash. When you’re being funded to pursue litigation, it’s not difficult to double down and appeal after a stinging loss. For Hall Chadwick partner Blair Pleash, trying to cajole a ceasefire from the bowels of defeat has meant being bitten twice in a month after the Federal Court of Appeal last week dismissed his bid to overturn a ruling rejecting his…
Hall Chadwick’s Ginette Muller. Marcus Watters of Hall Chadwick. Persuading a court to extend the deadline by which time you must commence proceedings can be a hard slog, particularly when your unfunded predecessors found nothing to see. Such however have been the travails recently endured by Jirsch Sutherland Brisbane partner Chris Baskerville and thoughtfully catalogued by Queensland Supreme Court judge Glen Martin in Baskerville v…
RSM partner Neil Cribb. Sheridan’s Jennifer Low. As best we can tell RSM partner and West Australia insolvency veteran Neil Cribb has chosen not to appeal the November 11 decision of Federal Court judge Neil McKerracher in Cribb v Kingsbury (No 2) [2021] FCA 1397. “No doubt such cases will come in many different forms, but certainly in this case I do not consider Mr Kingsbury’s…
Hamilton Murphy’s Stephen Dixon. Liquidator Ahmed Bise. Invalidity of appointment, inadequate attention to Consumer Credit codes, trespass even. Two recent judgments of Supreme Court of Victoria judge Peter Riordan show why it is wise to know one’s appointor, and even wiser to verify their security. Stephen Dixon and Ahmed Bise, the unfortunate pair in this salutary tale were, at the time of their first appointment…
Grocon Group deed administrator Craig Shepard. Hastie Group liquidator Craig Crosbie. There may well have been terse words, a chilling silence, or even diverse and inclusive profanity when KordaMentha’s Craig Shepard learned last week that Hastie Group liquidator Craig Crosbie had wrangled a decisive grant of leave. Shepherd – in his capacity as deed administrator of the Grocon Group – has been resisting efforts by…
Cor Cordis partner Andre Lakomy. A falling out between Sydney lender Graham Werry and notorious Kiwi businessman Mark Bryers has led a judge to mete out more punishment to litigation funders, and for good measure she’s also torn strips off a certain liquidator’s solvency reports. In the matter of Wetherill Park Holdings Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] NSWSC 1397 NSW Supreme Court judge Kelly Rees…
Cor Cordis partner Jason Tang. If you’re an administrator wanting the hearing of a winding up application adjourned so you can complete your report and convene a second meeting, Federal Court judge Angus Stewart ain’t your man. His honour, who iNO readers will recall presided over the the Commissioner of Taxation’s (CoT) model throttling of now ex-liquidator David Iannuzzi, pays close attention to the authorities….