dVT pair fined $10,000

Fined $10,000 dVT Group's Suelen McCallum
dVT’s Suelen McCallum.
fined $10,000 dVT's Riad Tayeh
dVT’s Riad Tayeh

dVT Group duo Suelen McCallum and Riad Tayeh have been fined $10,000 following an investigation by an ARITA Professional Conduct Committee (PCC).

ARITA convened the PCC to examine the pair’s acceptance of an appointment as liquidators of Hemisphere Technologies (HT), which these days is known as ACN 152 546 453 Pty Ltd.

Their appointment took place in January 2017, following some fast work by the director a month earlier.

On December 22, 2016, HT had sold its trade debtors, stock and certain documents and records to an entity called Hemisphere Technologies Australia Pty Ltd (HTA).

HTA was a company which in early 2016 had benefitted from the arrival of a new senior employee who had defected from HT’s secured creditor.

Then on December 23, 2016 HT changed its name to ACN 152 546 453 Pty Ltd.

The significance of these events is that on December 15 HT’s director had obtained a valuation of the assets subsequently sold on December 22 from none other than McCallum.

As is detailed by INO in Woodgate Appointed SPL As Creditor Shuns DVT Pair HT’s secured creditor was utterly opposed to the idea that the dVT duo should be the ones investigating the circumstances of that sale.

According to a statement published late yesterday by ARITA McCallum and Tayeh’s acceptance of the appointment constituted ” reckless, negligent or intentional behaviour or behaviour without mitigating factors within the scope of section 6.18.2C of the ARITA Code of Professional Practice”.

“The PCC determined that the following penalties be imposed pursuant clause 6.3 of the ARITA Regulations:

  • A financial penalty be imposed collectively against the members requiring them to pay $10,000 (the equivalent of the fees earned for provision of the precluded appointment advice) by way of a fine which ARITA will remit as a donation to The Ethics Centre to underline the importance of ethics and independence in the profession, and
  • A direction that the members attend ARITA’s Essential Skills – Insolvency: Independence course at the next available opportunity.”

ARITA said the only reason it didn’t seek to have the pair replaced was because Giles Woodgate had been appointed as a special purpose liquidator (SPL) in mid-2018 following an application by HT’s secured creditor in the NSW Supreme Court.

“However, this should not be interpreted as diminishing the seriousness of the determined breach of the independence requirements of the Code,” ARITA said.

As for the $10,000 the pair was fined, that, apparently, has already found its way to where it will further the cause of good governance.

“ARITA gratefully acknowledges the members’ immediate compliance in remitting the fine which has been on-paid by ARITA to The Ethics Centre.” Please take a moment to support INO’s continued chronicling of the insolvency profession.

About the Author

Peter Gosnell
Peter Gosnell
Insolvency News Online illuminates the practice of insolvency Australia-wide, highlighting the triumphs and travails of the nation’s registered practitioners and the accounting and legal professionals who work with them. INO is produced by Peter Gosnell, former business editor and senior business reporter at The Daily Telegraph newspaper. During a decade-long career, your correspondent reported on such notable corporate collapses as HIH, One.Tel, Westpoint and Fincorp as well as some of the nation's highest profile bankruptcies and the investigations and prosecutions arising from Australia's most notorious instances of white-collar crime.

4 Comments on "dVT pair fined $10,000"

  1. Not really a fine is it, ARITA? I mean, it’s just a reimbursement for the valuation job, whilst still retaining fees from the bigger external administration. (This comment has been edited).

  2. Could the $10,000 be instead provided to the secured creditor to meet some of their legal costs?

  3. Seems a tad soft fine…

  4. Well worth the risk. $10,000 is a joke.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*